Where the copier runs is not an implementation detail. It determines who holds your broker credentials, how far your orders travel, who is responsible when it stops, and what happens to you if the vendor has a bad day.
The credential question, in detail
This is the difference that matters most and gets discussed least, so it is worth being precise about what a cloud copier necessarily has.
To place an order on your slave account, the vendor’s server logs into that account. To do that at 3am while you are asleep, it must hold a credential that works at 3am — not a one-time token you approved, but a standing login. On MetaTrader that is an investor or master password; on cTrader it is an OAuth grant or a stored login. Whatever the mechanism, the practical position is the same: a company you have never met can authenticate as you, on all of your accounts, at any time, until you change the password.
Most of these companies are honest and some are competent. That is not the issue. The issue is that you cannot verify either claim, and the aggregate database — thousands of traders, tens of thousands of live logins — is a target whose value has nothing to do with the vendor’s intentions. Security questions to put to any hosted copier, in order:
- Are trading passwords stored encrypted at rest, and who holds the decryption key?
- Can staff access the credential store? Under what controls, and is that logged?
- Has an external party ever audited it, and can you see the result?
- What happens to stored credentials when you cancel — deleted, or retained in backups?
- What is their published incident history, and how were breaches disclosed?
A self-hosted copier makes all five questions moot, because it never receives the credential in the first place. Passwords sit in the operating system’s own keystore — Windows Credential Manager, macOS Keychain — on the machine running the terminal.
The latency question, with realistic numbers
Copier marketing quotes millisecond figures with more confidence than the physics deserves. Here is the shape of it. In a self-hosted setup, master and slave terminals sit on one machine, so the copy itself is a local hand-off — commonly in the tens of milliseconds, and the meaningful remaining delay is each terminal’s own round trip to its broker.
In a cloud setup, the same copy involves your master’s broker reporting the fill, the vendor receiving it, the vendor deciding and dispatching, and then the slave broker executing. That is at least two additional wide-area trips plus whatever queueing the vendor has under load — and the load spikes exactly when everyone’s strategies fire at once, on the news release you cared about.
The honest caveat: for most trading styles this difference is not the thing costing you money. Swing and position trading will not notice. Broker-side execution quality and the spread difference between two brokers usually dominate. It matters for scalping, for news trading, and for anything on an instrument that gaps — which is a real minority of traders, not all of them.
Who is responsible when it stops
Cloud copying transfers the operational burden to the vendor. That is a genuine benefit and the main reason the model exists. But it also transfers control: when their service degrades at 14:30 on a Friday, your options are to watch the status page and to place your trades manually. Self-hosting keeps both the burden and the control — a copier on a VPS you rent fails for reasons you can inspect and fix.
Neither is strictly safer. A well-run cloud has better uptime than a laptop; a well-chosen VPS has better uptime than most small vendors. The question is not which is more reliable in the abstract, it is which failure you would rather be able to do something about.
The fair summary: cloud copiers trade custody of your credentials for freedom from operations. That is a real trade, not a scam, and for a small account it can be the right one. It stops being the right one at roughly the point where the accounts being copied are large enough, or borrowed enough, that you would not want a stranger able to log into them.
R4Copier is self-hosted, so treat this page as informed rather than neutral — but the ledger above is the one we would give you if you decided to buy someone else’s product. If you want the architecture argument in full, it continues on the self-hosted page and the credential page.